BC Teachers Federation taking “wait-and-see” approach on cell phones in classrooms

Should cell phones be banned in BC classrooms?

That’s a question being asked across many school districts province-wide. Quebec and Ontario have recently adopted limits on personal use of electronic devices except for learning activities.

BC Teacher Federation President Clint Johnston told Vista Radio their organization is taking a wait-and-see approach and that a blanket policy for all districts to follow might not be the best decision.

“I think it would be hard to write something that works for everyone everywhere across the province but I think rather than boards and districts dictating it. We think there should be a process where it involves students in classrooms and learning and teachers. It should involve a conversation with all parties to decide what is practical and what isn’t.”

“We are aware this is an issue. There certainly can be some negative effects on attention and managing a classroom but many of our members are happy to use them as resources to help us support the learning of students in classes. I would say that we wrap it in with all of the work we are doing, talking about how technology can be provided equitably – I think that is a more interesting conversation. Why are students bringing their cell phones to school and needing to use them in the classroom? How can we make sure every student has access to it equitably?”

Laura Weller is the District Parent Advisory Council Chair in PG said while she appreciates the topic being brought into the spotlight, it’s far from a front-burner issue.

“I don’t see it being a top priority at all, yeah the logic is there in following what they did (Quebec and Ontario) but BC is a leader in so many other ways. If this isn’t something that the province and Ministry of Education and Childcare level is going to take attention away from other activities I don’t think it’s a big deal.”

She added while steps can be made to limit phone use without a policy, it’s hard to know where the line should be drawn.

“I think that most learning and collaboration environments could be improved without devices at hand all the time, especially in the educational environment in public schools. Where do you draw the line? Again, it comes back to schools and the discretion of the teachers and educators in the classroom.”

The Ministry of Education issued the following statement to Vista Radio regarding the topic:

• The Ministry of Education and Child Care recognizes some Provinces and regions are leaving it up to districts and boards to implement and enforce, while some other regions put limitations on cell phone use in schools.
• While school districts in B.C. currently manage cell phone use, many districts have policies in place restricting student cell phone access at school. Principals and teachers also can restrict cell phone use in classrooms.
• There are instances where having access to technology is used as a learning tool and for some students, it is important for accessibility. 
• The Ministry continues its work to monitor and evaluate the issue, as student health and well-being are of the utmost importance to support their continued success.

School District 57 has responded to MyPGNow.com’s request for an interview and may give a response shortly.